MTG, also known as Magic, is a card game created by Richard Garfield. Magic: The Gathering (MTG) has become immensely popular since 1993. It continues to thrive with a wide range of formats for players to explore. Two unique ways to enjoy the game are Elder Dragon Highlander (EDH) and Competitive EDH (CEDH).
What is EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander)?
The Elder Dragon Highlander format, also known as EDH or Commander, came from fans. It was made to promote creativity, social interactions, and casual play in MTG. The name “Elder Dragon Highlander” harkens back to the format’s early days when Elder Dragons were often chosen as commanders.
Unique features of EDH
EDH is characterized by a set of unique features, making it distinct from other MTG formats. Build singleton decks with exactly 100 cards. Choose a legendary creature as commander. The singleton rule makes sure that no cards in the deck have the same name. The commander’s colour identity determines which cards can be in the deck.
EDH Rules and Deck Building
In EDH, players build decks consisting of exactly 100 cards, including their commander. The commander plays a central role in the deck, and players can cast it from the command zone. Losing a commander to a command zone can raise casting costs, adding a strategic layer.
Singleton rule
One of the core principles of EDH is the singleton rule. This means that players can include only one copy of each card (excluding basic lands) in their deck. This rule encourages creativity and diversity in deck construction.
Colour identity
A commander’s colour identity decides the mana colours and cards in the deck. A blue and white commander lets you use cards with blue, white, and colourless mana symbols.
Gameplay in EDH
EDH is known for its multiplayer format, with games often involving four or more players. EDH is great for interacting and forming alliances to defeat opponents. Games can be long and epic, with complex boards and strategies.
In EDH, the goal is usually to make opponents’ life totals reach zero to win. EDH is not all about winning quickly. It’s about having fun and connecting with other players.
Diving into CEDH
CEDH is a competitive subset of Commander that focuses on optimizing gameplay. Competitive EDH gained popularity due to its fast and cutthroat nature. Players aim for efficient, game-winning strategies.
Emergence of CEDH
CEDH emerged as a response to the desire for a more competitive and strategic version of EDH. EDH is all about fun, being social, and being creative, but CEDH is all about winning efficiently. The shift in focus has created unique traits that make CEDH different.
Distinct characteristics of CEDH
CEDH decks are finely tuned for maximum speed and consistency. In CEDH, players use strong cards and execute game-winning combos early in the game. This makes CEDH an entirely different beast compared to traditional EDH.
CEDH Deck Building and Rules
In CEDH, deck building is the art of optimization. Players use the best cards and combos to win quickly. The cards’ synergy is designed to create scenarios that opponents find hard to stop.
The ban list in CEDH
CEDH has its ban list, which differs from the traditional EDH ban list. To keep the game fair and exciting, we ban cards that are too strong or disruptive in competitive play. The ban list is regularly updated to address the evolving CEDH landscape.
Gameplay in CEDH
CEDH games are notably faster than EDH games. In CEDH games, players want to win quickly, so casual play is limited. EDH games are social and diplomatic, but CEDH games are intense and focused on winning.
Key Differences Between EDH and CEDH
EDH and CEDH have different deck-building philosophies. EDH encourages creativity and diversity, while CEDH prioritizes optimization and efficiency. EDH decks have themes and less powerful cards, while CEDH focuses on combos and the best cards.
Power Level
EDH is a laid-back and social format with different power levels and interactions. In contrast, CEDH is highly competitive and features fast-paced, high-powered gameplay. CEDH decks are finely tuned machines designed for one purpose: victory.
Banlist Variations
EDH and CEDH have different ban lists. EDH aims to balance power and fun, while CEDH has a stricter ban list for competitive games. The ban list variations reflect the differing goals of each format.
Gameplay Dynamics
The gameplay dynamics in EDH and CEDH are significantly different. EDH games are often long and social, with a focus on creativity and interaction. CEDH games are quick and intense, with players racing to achieve victory. The competitive environment in CEDH leads to different strategies and interactions.
Related Article: What MTG Card Has the Highest Power and Toughness?
Similarities Between EDH and CEDH
Both EDH and CEDH place a significant emphasis on the commander. The commander is a central part of the deck and often dictates the overall strategy. Losing a commander to the command zone can greatly impact the game in both formats.
Social Aspect
Despite their differences, both formats retain a social aspect. In both EDH and CEDH, players often talk, team up, and have fun with others in MTG.
Diverse Strategies
While CEDH decks are highly optimized, they still offer diverse strategies and playstyles. Each commander and deck type in EDH and CEDH offers different gameplay experiences.
Choosing Between EDH and CEDH
When deciding whether to play EDH or CEDH, there are several factors to consider. Your playstyle, preferences, and the local MTG community affect your decision.
If you like relaxed games where you can be creative and try new things, EDH is a great choice. CEDH is thrilling for those who seek competitive, fast gameplay and optimised decks.
Controversies and Debates
The MTG community has had many debates and controversies about EDH and CEDH. The most prominent debate revolves around the balance between competitive and casual play. CEDH disrupts the spirit of EDH: it focuses on winning while others enjoy MTG in different ways.
The future of both formats remains an open question. MTG is evolving, so EDH and CEDH will change with player preferences and the card pool.
Community Resources and Forums
If you want to learn more about EDH and CEDH, there are websites, forums, and communities for each format. These platforms offer deck-building advice, strategy discussions, and the opportunity to connect with other players who share your interests.
Notable EDH and CEDH Decks
To better understand each format, it’s good to check out some notable decks. Here are examples of popular EDH and competitive CEDH decks:
Examples of popular EDH decks:
- “Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice” Superfriends .
- “The Gitrog Monster” Lands Matter.
- “Edgar Markov” Vampire Tribal.
Examples of competitive CEDH decks:
- “Thrasios, Triton Hero” and “Tymna the Weaver” Consultation.
- “Kess, Dissident Mage” Storm.
- “Tasigur, the Golden Fang” Control.
The Role of Card Availability
One consideration when choosing between EDH and CEDH is the availability of cards. CEDH decks need strong and costly cards, which may not be affordable for some players. In contrast, EDH offers more flexibility in card choices, making it more budget-friendly.
Investing in EDH and CEDH
MTG cards have value, and their prices can fluctuate over time. EDH and CEDH cards have their values in the market, and some become collectable. When buying cards, players should know about their value and future potential.
Influence of MTG Tournaments
Magic: The Gathering has a thriving competitive scene with various tournaments and events. EDH and CEDH are mostly casual formats, but they have also been played in tournaments. Understanding the influence of these formats in the broader MTG competitive scene is essential for players looking to explore different aspects of the game.
Conclusion:
In the end, the choice between EDH and CEDH boils down to personal preference. Both formats bring fun and are suitable for different players. If you enjoy socializing and being creative while playing, go for EDH. But if you prefer a more competitive experience, CEDH is for you. MTG has options for everyone.
